Much hey has been made over the past year or two over the usage of the Constraint-Led Approach (CLA) to training jiu jitsu. Proponents argue that CLA is a superior pedagogical approach for developing adaptable athletes. Conversely, critics of this approach have argued that what CLA provides comes at the cost of technical precision and efficiency.
Let me be upfront and clear, I am not going to argue for or against CLA. This is because, as with many debates surrounding pedagogical approaches, the discussion of CLA’s usage has become one of either “For” or “Against” with not much middle ground being provided. And that is simply not how educational pedagogy works.
The whole discussion reminds me of a video from a decade ago by video game journalist James Stephanie Sterling on the topic of choices and pasta sauce.
The video centers mostly around consumer choice but it involved a useful anecdote of a market researcher who was hired to the pasta sauce company Prego to figure what is “the best pasta sauce” that would give them the market edge they were seeking. The researcher wound up conducting numerous blind taste tests with various flavors of pasta sauce and he came to the conclusion that, really, the customer has far more varied preferences than anyone from the pasta companies anticipated.
In short: “there is no perfect pasta sauce, only perfect pasta sauces.”
I think this line is very applicable when it comes to pedagogical approaches. Any competent teacher will tell you that one approach does not work universally.
Different pedagogical approaches have been used by educators for, well, centuries. This is because educators (be it tutors for nobles, teachers in classrooms, or the dreaded educational researcher) were all attempting to solve different problems within the same space. Some of these approaches are amazing at developing technical proficiency and procedural knowledge. This in jiu jitsu contexts may come in the form of focused drilling that those from wrestling backgrounds or even judo backgrounds implement.
Other pedagogical approaches excel more in the development of quick decision-making, creativity, and adaptability and typically come from the actual action of doing things on the fly. A system wherein the student learns not through rote memorization or direct instruction but through exploration and experimentation. If you want to tie this to jiu jitsu it’d be akin to a coach not necessarily providing clear details on what specifically to do, but to put you in the situation and let you figure out what is or isn’t working and to build off of that. In general, skill development in jiu jitsu is heavily influenced by this educational philosophy with fairly obvious reasons: people’s bodies are differently shaped, their flexibility/athleticism vary, and certain body mechanics and timing are simply easier to develop in this manner than through pure traditional drilling.
The reality is that one approach is effective at achieving a particular and specific outcome. However, that does not mean it automatically is effective at achieving all outcomes. Which is where these discussions on pedagogical approaches in jiu jitsu get fairly frustrating as a fair number of people I’ve noticed have taken the stance that there is only one perfect pasta sauce, not perfect pasta sauces.
And, unsurprisingly, this is where these debates go off the rails from trying to provide a solid educational approach for students and become more of a pissing contest between coaches. The mistake that is being made is that because one approach has been effective, it should therefore be exclusively used for all students and skill developments.
Students who are beginners in the sport are not necessarily confronted with the same problems with their skill development as compared to more experienced athletes. Likewise, a competition focused practitioner may have different developmental focuses compared to the hobbyist that is just there to burn some calories. This is, again, a long way of saying that different contexts (student taxonomy, focuses, etc.) call for a range of instructional methods available in the instructor’s approach.
This is, again, why this “debate” has been somewhat frustrating to see play out. Rather than asking which pedagogical approach is best for student development, I would argue that it is more useful to ask: what is this particular approach best at accomplishing, and does it suit the learning outcomes we are intending?
This reframes pedagogical approaches less as competing ideologies and more like the aforementioned tools available to the instructor. The value they provide depends entirely upon the task at hand, the learning contexts of both the students and scenario being looked at, and what the key takeaways you want your student to have. All of which exist and work in traditional education spaces, meaning it very much still applies to jiu jitsu. We don’t need to reinvent the wheel here folks.
So let’s examine several common pedagogical approaches that can be typically found within grappling sports (jiu jitsu, wrestling, judo). Rather than focus on which is the best, let’s focus on the strengths, limitations, and application of each to help explore how hybridization is a more effective approach.
With this all in mind, it should therefore be no surprise that coaches will, intentionally or unintentionally, draw upon pedagogical approaches to help transfer their knowledge to their students. These approaches include, but are not limited to; (1) direct instruction, (2) traditional drilling, (3) guided discovery, (4) constraint-led approaches, (5) ecological dynamics-informed instruction, and forms of deliberate practice. As I mentioned earlier, there is tendency within jiu jitsu to treat these approaches as competing ideologies, but they are best understood as occupying different roles and positions within the spectrum of pedagogy.
Direct instruction is easily the most familiar and understood approach. The coach demonstrates the technique, explains specific details relevant to it, and the students attempt to replicate what they were shown and told to do. This is, actually, one of the strongest forms of pedagogical approaches for jiu jitsu especially amongst beginners. This approach allows for a coach to transmit the information they need to pass on to students while simultaneously establishing a standard baseline for technical proficiency. In addition, it also helps introduce unfamiliar movements and body mechanics in a shortened and rapid-fire format. All of which is essential for beginners as it can reduce cognitive overload by setting clear step-by-step instructions they can rely upon to reach the desired outcome.
Accompanying this approach is traditional drilling where the student repeatedly performs a set movement pattern in a controlled environment to develop timing, movement familiarity, and technical precision and proficiency. In judo they would refer to this as “uchikomi”, something jiu jitsu in general should be more willing to rely and utilize more often. Drilling is quite useful during the early stages of skill acquisition. I say “skill acquisition” but do not be confused thinking this just means white belts, this means any time you’re learning a new technique or skill. This is because when learning a new technique its important to understand the fundamental mechanics of it, which traditional drilling allows for the student to do again in a controlled environment rather than just throwing it out when they’re in the middle of a match However, the drawback to traditional drilling is that there is a lack of realistic responses the uke will provide the tori when doing them. Yet, such a criticism of this approach should not obscure the fact that repetition remains a vitally important component to motor skill development. Meaning while traditional drilling may not be realistic, and arguably monotonous in a sense, it is still a highly efficient way to develop technical skills.
Anecdotally, when I was training in South Korea at the end of the night after the final night class ended you’d see the more competition focused students in their 20s head off to the side of the mat and do another half an hour or so of uchikomi (I’m stealing the name judokas, sorry). It would then be no surprise that during a competition they’d be quite good at hitting the technique they were drilling after class. Such is the value is traditional drilling and why it is, arguably, one of the strongest forms of skill development out there.
Occupying a middle ground between academic education and experiential education in the realm of jiu jitsu sits guided discovery. This is where a student, through their own agency, seeks out an answer to a problem they’re facing rather than being passive and waiting for the answer to be given to them. As a result, this approach can help improve individual students’ ability to understand and retain technical information as the student is actively engaged with the problem rather than engaging in rote memorization. If you’ve ever engaged in any sort of “game” where you’re meant to reach a goal with a technique, you’re probably sitting in this category of approach. Which is great because, as Rousseau argued, it keeps the learner engaged and active rather than passive.
Continuing this shift towards more problem-solving oriented approaches is the much discussed Constraint-Led Approach. Under CLA, a coach introduces artificial constraints such as specific objectives, rules, or available actions the students can engage in. The goal here is for students to learn through this limitation of available options and develop specific skills under those constraints. The core strength of CLA is in its capacity to develop adaptable students who can make decisions under more realistic conditions. Think of a game where you’re scenario is you’re down by 1 point with 30 seconds and your sole objective is to get a takedown to take the lead. This would be a CLA oriented learning activity. Because the students are exposed to variability and resistance from the outset of the start, skill development may transfer more readily towards live rolling and competition contexts.
With all this in mind, each of these approaches possess limitations when used in pure isolation. For example, direct instruction in rapid succession can cause cognitive overload. Too much reliance on exploratory learning approaches can result in confusion and omission of core technical details being developed first. The problem isn’t which one approach is flawed, they all are in their own way. The problem is each approach emphasizes particular learning outcomes while simultaneously neglecting others to do so.
This is why the question should not be which pedagogical approach is superior. A more productive line of discussion is what approach helps create the desired learning outcome for that student at that particular stage of development within that particular context.
Effective jiu jitsu coaching is less a commitment to a single pedagogical philosophy. Which makes sense because no teacher is wholly reliant on one singular approach, there is always a need for adaptability. In reality, the best coaches understand that multiple approaches are usable and focus on when to implement them.
There is no perfect teaching approach, only perfect teaching approaches.



